Just like any job, dog training requires using the right tools. Using the wrong tools can lead to unwanted behaviors in your dog and frustration for you. Usually the issue isn’t the tool, but it’s how it’s being applied. I often tell my clients that whacking a screw with a hammer doesn’t do much good. So what are the right tools to use for basic obedience and behavior modifications?
The best tools for basic obedience and behavior modifications depend entirely on the dog’s needs. Each dog is unique and requires their own approach for being trained. The approach to train an aggressive dog is way different than the approach to train a skittish dog. Thus, the need for different tools. All any trainer can do that will actually benefit you without meeting your dog is to give you a general idea of the tools you should be open to using and tools that you should stop using to prevent unwanted behaviors.
Choosing the right collar is a great start when preparing to train your dog. Collars can be the difference of life or death in some cases. Using the wrong collar could allow your dog to slip out and run into traffic. I’ve also seen plenty of collars break from strong pullers. I don’t like relying on the buckle in or belt flat collars that every dog has their tag on. The buckle breaks and the part that the leash connects to is often a flimsy tack weld instead of a strong weld or it’s not even welded together at all on the backside and can stretch apart. The buckle in ones are also very annoying to adjust the size on.
You don’t want to use a harness for basic obedience or behavior modifications because they are designed to allow the dog to pull with minimum corrective pressure. This makes them great tools for sporting activities like sled pulling, protection training, and teaching them to swim. However, that’s where the line should be drawn with the harness. You are confusing the dog by using it on a walk and getting upset with them when they pull. Not only that, but holding them back in such a way can actually build drive in the dog to keep pulling. You on the other hand will lose determination to go on that daily walk.
I use and recommend only three kinds of collars. I’m not a huge fan of martingales or gentle leaders. The martingale is a strange mix between a flat and slip collar and I don’t think it’s very good at either. The gentle leader I see used of reactive dogs mostly and it acts as more of a distraction than what their initial triggers were. Distracting your dog is avoidance, not training. Once the dog gets used to the gentle leader I find the correction does not get the same results as the collars I recommend, so I don’t consider it when talking about useful tools.
The first of three collars that I recommend is the flat collar. Above I did in fact say that I’m not a fan of the buckle or belt collar which are flat collars and I stand by that, but there is a useful and safe kind of flat collar. It’s the fur saver. Fur savers are actually slip collars but you can connect it back to itself using the leash to create a flat collar. This is a metal collar with large oval links. It will never break and is very easy to adjust the size on so you can assure that it won’t slip off of your dog if you have it on right. I consider the flat collar to be a level one collar. Base level is off leash. If you only need a flat collar to give your dog productive feedback then you’re close to being able to trust them off leash.
The next collar, level two, is the slip collar. This is most useful on small dogs with such little body weight that a flat collar doesn’t mean anything to them when corrected with. A good slip collar tightens and loosens very easily to assure swift functionality when needed and your dog’s safety after use. A bad slip collar will stay tight after corrections and not only be causing miscommunication, but it will be choking your dog. We don’t want that. We also don’t want the dog to slip out of the collar when there’s no pressure so be sure there’s a good stopper on it. I don’t like the leather stoppers because they ware and start to loosen very easily. I only use slip collars that have a spring loaded clip stopper. This way when you set how tight the collar should be to assure your dog can’t slip out, you know for certain that it is going to stay in that position. I never leave the slip collar on the dog when I’m not with them.
The third collar I sometimes recommend, level three, is the prong collar. This collar helps very reactive dogs snap out of it. It also helps weaker handlers to communicate with a newer dog that isn’t focused on the handler yet. This collar can just as dangerous as it is useful, so you need to know what to consider when getting and using one. Only use this for training and don’t leave it on the dog. You don’t want your dog to get hurt or too used to it. Only use a martingale prong collar. The flat prong functions differently and can hurt your dog while the martingale prong collar applies pressure evening around the neck at an angle. Use a fail safe when using a prong collar. I use the slip collar so if my prong comes undone I still have a level two collar on the dog so the walk home or to the car isn’t miserable and counterproductive.
E-collars are fine when used properly. If conditioned well the dog will actually see the collar as something good. When used poorly you get the nightmare stories of dogs turning aggressive or skittish because of it. I will cover the E-collar in a different post because it requires much more detail. I believe it’s similar to gun use; if you know how to use it and respect its’ power it can be a great tool, but in the wrong hands or even just the untrained hands it can lead to horrific events and make you wish they didn’t exist at all. I also find that I can get same result from just using a long line until I completely trust the dog, but don’t want people’s fear of them to keep from the use of a great tool if necessary. I just find that it’s an extra step to teach handlers when I can get their companion dog to recall well enough even when distracted without the use of one.
Leashes! The leash is an extension of yourself that connects you to your dog. This is how you will transfer your energy to the dog until they just listen to vocal commands. It’s important that you become a fluent handler of the leash with commonly required movements so when it’s needed you aren’t left tangled up getting dragged towards a squirrel by your dog. I recommend practicing making loops and then letting go one loop at a time and then looping again. See how quick you can get at that without it even being on your dog. Make sure your leash isn’t too slippery. I tie knots in my leashes. In a six foot leash I’ll tie one or two knots at the handler’s end, one in the middle, and one about a foot before the clip. This helps with grip and consistency with hand placements.
I use two leashes for basic obedience and behavior modifications. The first and main leash I use is a six foot leash. Like I said above, I tie a few knots in it to help grip and consistency. When getting a new leash I make sure it has no stretch to it at all. I don’t want my energy from the correction to be absorbed by the leash before it makes it to the dog. This leads to frustration for the handler and unclear communication. Materials that are good for this are thin nylon, aged leather, and my current favorite - biothane. While there’s nothing better than the feel of good leather grip-wise, biothane comes stretch free and leather has some stretch to it at first.
The other leash I use is a fifteen to twenty foot long line. I tie knots every few feet in it. I drop the long line a lot to give the dog more freedom, but if I need to grab it I can just step on the leash and the knots keep it from slipping from under my foot while the dog is running away. You also want to make sure there’s no stretch with the long line. Your correction can really be muffled by elasticity in the line. Long leashes should be light in weight so I only recommend the thin nylon ones. Practice extra with the long line with the loop and release exercise I described above.
With any leash I give a pull test. Step on one end and pull upwards as hard as you can and hold it there for a few seconds. If it wears or breaks throw it out for your dog’s safety. Also look out for the stitching on the handle and especially by the clip. I trust the box x stitch or a straight stitch that is at least two inches long. Any shorter for a straight stitch probably won’t last you a lifetime with your large dog and you never know when it will fail on you. Finally, you should check the clip. The most common clip is a swivel hook with a plunger latch. Be sure the track where the spring rests is not too wide. The spring or latch should not be able to slip out. This could cause the leash to let go of the collar and create an unintentional off leash experience.
Bungee and retractable leashes are not very useful for most of basic obedience or behavior modifications. A bungee leash allows the dog to pull and even lightens the blow for them when they sprint away from their handler. You don’t want that. Bungee leashes are great for protection training to reduce the tension the dog feels while they’re supposed to be pulling. I like them for building play drive in dogs. I’ll connect the leash to a post, have the dog on a harness and tease them with the toy before finally letting them get it.
Retractable leashes break easily and tempt handlers with poor behaviors. “If the dog is pulling with just six feet of leash why don’t I give them more leash?” is a flawed way of thinking and tells your dog that you have flexible boundaries that they can choose not to listen to because you’ll cave and give them what they want. It’s doing more of a disservice to your dog than correcting them to teach them proper leash manners is. The retractable leash is infamous for breaking. In the rare cases that I recommend it, the dog is very light in weight and the handler is unable to be fast enough with the long line to safely operate it. The retractable handle also makes the correction more of a row which engages the back more than a correction should. A correction should be an effortless wrist and elbow snap like using a whip, not a workout.
One of the most important tools in dog training is a high quality treat. At home the dog may listen for any old snack, but in public they may be too distracted at first to care about anything but real and raw meat. Hotdogs are the cheapest and most used by dog trainers. They may be too rich for your dog at first, but they’ll get used to it unless they have an allergy to the type of hotdog meat you’re giving them. You can use most any meat for training your dog. Cut them into pea-sized bits so it doesn’t take too long for your dog to chew and they last much longer that way. As time goes on I start to mix their kibble in with the meat and wean the dogs off of the meat so they just listen for their regular food in any environment.
You can also use vegan substitutes. I personally like this option since I’m vegan. My dog and cat eat vegan food designed to give them all of the nutrients needed for their species to live long and healthy lives. I try not too buy meat when I can avoid it because I’m personally vegan, but I do also understand that dogs all go insane for real meat. It’s a part of being a pet owner, but there are ways to avoid having to buy it such as becoming friends with your local butcher or restaurant manager to see if they can put aside some scraps meat for you. They’ll usually give you a garbage bag worth of meat, fresh from that day - which is better than what’s in your dry kibble - to take home and preserve and use as treats or regular food. Make sure not to give them just fat to avoid conditions like obesity and pancreatitis.
A treat pouch is a necessary accessory for dog training. Not your pocket, not a Ziploc. A pouch like a fanny pack or in my preference just a clip on bag that is very easy and quick for my to get the treat out of. With treat pouches you’ll find there’s a balance of cleanliness and durability. The ones that are easy to clean break easily and the pouches that don’t break easy are annoying to clean. Find what works for you. I use both all the time and go through phases of which kind I prefer. You also want to make sure the treats don’t fall out when you bend over. I prefer a magnet or and snap shut pouch rather than the shoe string or zipper kinds.
Those are most of the tools that I use. I’ll do another post about toys that I recommend. I’m very selective about the types of toys I use and how to use them. You can also get a place mat for your dog. I recommend a raised dog cot. It’s easier to teach place with those. More on the E-collar later. Feel free to reach out with any questions on anything covered here or dog related in general. I hope this post has helped.